Can Blockchain really offer a way out of the Brexit quagmire?

For those following the continuing Brexit crisis in the UK, there have been many issues not least of which is solving the "Irish border" issue. If you need more context on this issue, see the following video by Vox Atlas which does an amazing job of summarizing the issues in about 7 minutes:


What does this have to Blockchain?

Well, it seems that blockchain was identified as a possible solution for this situation. I came across this idea from an article in CCN, which stated the following:

"According to Phillip Hammond, UK’s finance minister, the best way to ensure trade across the Irish border remains frictionless after Britain leaves the EU lies in the use of blockchain technology.

“There is technology becoming available (…) I don’t claim to be an expert on it but the most obvious technology is blockchain,” Reuters reported Hammond as having answered after being asked what the government was proposing to do to ensure smooth trade after Brexit."

I followed the Reuters link but it didn't add much context to the quote; how can blockchain offer any relief from the issues related to the customs union and hard border?

But then I found an article on FT, which stated the following:

"It is safe to say technology used at the border is a red herring, as even the best database can't poke its nose inside a lorry. Here, for instance, is one of the IT experts quoted in the Irish Times calling the idea of technological solutions to the border question “complete nonsense”...

Wired also looked at tech solutions for dealing with 6,000 heavy goods vehicles per day crossing the border, and decided that they were “untested or imaginary”. Blockchain as a border solution is both.

So what inspired Hammond to jump on the blockwagon? It might have been a “white paper” literally called “Blockchain for Brexit”, released last week by Reply Ltd, a consultancy which promised a “solution that could save global businesses billions of pounds through seamless border checks and virtually infallible tracking systems for their goods”."

Although I have commented that blockchainthusiasts need to be careful about overstating the capabilities of the blockchain (such as replacing the need for financial audits), we can hardly blame blockchainthusiasm here. Rather it's the Wizard-of-Oz trick of hiding behind the magic curtain. But this time it's not a magic trick but rather the complexity of technology that some are attempting use to gloss some key issues that have emerged in the aftermath of Brexit.

Technology at the end of the day is just a tool fashioned by human beings and is not God. It can't magically solve complex business problems let alone extremely complex political issues that have been simmering for centuries.

Author: Malik Datardina, CPA, CA, CISA. Malik works at Auvenir as a GRC Strategist that is working to transform the engagement experience for accounting firms and their clients. The opinions expressed here do not necessarily represent UWCISA, UW, Auvenir (or its affiliates), CPA Canada or anyone else